Jump to content

Scum in coolant reservoir


Recommended Posts

Did my weekly check of the Octy yesterday morning before taking it for a long drive.  It's done a total of 1200km.
Oil looked super clean and hadn't moved in level since I collected the car a month ago.
BUT
Found this oily smelling and oily feeling fluid inside the coolant reservoir, and all this scum floating on the top of the red coolant. Immediately panicked that the engine was blown - I've heard of water in the oil before, but never oil in the water.

Urgent call to Skoda service dude at the dealership and described it, and he assured me that if the temp gauge never moves (it sits on a dedicated 90degrees) and the coolant level (without the scum) was between the min & max markers, then it was completely safe to drive.
He described the scum as remnants of slight lubrication fluids left inside the cooling system when the car was manufactured, which has just mixed with the coolant and caused the sludge.

What he described sounds reasonable to me, but I just want to know if anyone else has encountered this before?
I've had previous engines rebuilt & refitted and never found that in my coolant.

It's due for it's complimentary 1500km inspection (it's not really a service) next weekend, so I've asked them to make sure they do a complete drain, flush & refill of my cooling system, which they've agreed to do.

post-148193-0-66935900-1476597297_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As above, the scum in your tank is not a normal feature.

 

Somebody has either accidentally poured oil into the coolant reservoir or you have a major issue developing.

 

Coolant should be a pink colour, as you look into the coolant reservoir on a new vehicle it should ppear clear & pink.

 

I would treat the mess you have in your tank as an item urgently requiring a Skoda Assist visit.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yep - I agree it doesn't look right.

 

Have emailed them some more photos I took tonight - I've driven about 350km further since he told me yesterday it was OK to drive, so we'll see what they say tomorrow when they see the photos.

The sludge is very smooth and runny today - yesterday it was lumpy like soggy old cereal.

 

Coolant is still above minimum level, but is lower than it was yesterday - and the sludge layer looks thicker than yesterday too.

 

post-148193-0-45286900-1476609919_thumb.jpg

post-148193-0-21518200-1476609920_thumb.jpg

post-148193-0-74562700-1476609920_thumb.jpg

post-148193-0-25444000-1476609921_thumb.jpg

post-148193-0-11004000-1476609922_thumb.jpg

post-148193-0-61522000-1476609922_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well the engine oil looks perfect.  Nice colour and hasn't changed level since I picked up the car.  It's definitely not milky, the way I would expect it to be with a blown head gasket.

 

However, I'm unsure of the oil cooler arrangement.

 

Unless - as someone else has suggested - someone accidentally filled the wrong reservoir with oil instead of coolant, and it simply hasn't been flushed properly, and they're just trying to keep a bit quiet about it thinking they've already flushed the system sufficiently?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I`ve had an oil cooler failure on my old diesel Seat but didn`t look anything like yours. All my coolant turned into a black oily liquid. I was travelling long distance so I didn't`t notice until the next morning when the coolant warning light was flashing at me.

 

Got it replaced and I had to flush the reservoir for about 10 times until the oil disappeared from the system.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Too much gunge there for it to align with their excuse about original manufacture debri. Milky appearance for light oil/water mix but added heat and mixing makes a big difference. Clearly needs some quick and in-depth investigation so insist on full written report of their investigations and findings, and at absolute minimum a full flush until you yourself see nice clear pink coolant (and I would check and record after their checks just for your absolute surety). Hope you get it sorted without further excuses.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Too much gunge there for it to align with their excuse about original manufacture debri. Milky appearance for light oil/water mix but added heat and mixing makes a big difference. Clearly needs some quick and in-depth investigation so insist on full written report of their investigations and findings, and at absolute minimum a full flush until you yourself see nice clear pink coolant (and I would check and record after their checks just for your absolute surety). Hope you get it sorted without further excuses.

 

Agreed that it looks excessive.  And my description over the phone on saturday morning may not have fully-conveyed the true extent of the scum involved - even though I made it pretty clear it was funky stuff inside the reservoir!

 

Will do as you've suggested - I've already insisted on a full flush/clean, but I'm going to make sure I have everything documented clearly.

The dealer I purchased from is 2-hours drive away, but there is a closer dealer that I will probably have to end up dealing with, if it turns out to be a serious issue that needs immediate work.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They should be able to do a sniff test on the coolant. It's quick and will answer the question.

 

That would only detect hydrocarbons in the water where exhaust gasses are getting in to the cooling circuit as a result of HGF between a cooling gallery and a cylinder

 

HGF can also occur between oil and water galleries and the higher pressure oil is forced into the coolant (as appears to be the case in this thread) and wont be picked up by sniffer test :)

 

Whatever is at fault, the car here is in danger of critical damage from compromised cooling/lubrication IF HGF and I'd have them collect it asap - that's very unlikely to be remnants from manufacture - way, way too much.

Edited by Wakey
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oil in coolant can be a faulty head gasket, oil cooler or turbo charger.

I dont understand why that schould be a danger of critical damage.

Water in oil is a different story.

Let them flush the coolant system and see what happens.

I had this problem on my Octavia mk1 1.8-20v, and used it daily for almost a year before I changed the headgasket.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oil in coolant can be a faulty head gasket, oil cooler or turbo charger.

I dont understand why that schould be a danger of critical damage.

Water in oil is a different story.

Let them flush the coolant system and see what happens.

I had this problem on my Octavia mk1 1.8-20v, and used it daily for almost a year before I changed the headgasket.

 

Because if the oil continues to contaminate the water it can clog up the narrow coolant galleries in the cylinder head and turbo and lead to overheating, blockages, hotspots all generally not good

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's there to filter the coolant. It's just like a silica bag you get in a box of trainer etc but a bit more robust. They can split which causes the coolant to coagulate.

A new header tank (with the silica in a capsule rather than a bag) and a flush out will usually see you right.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wouldn't have driven it out of the dealers like that myself.

Whatever the cause, the coolant system isn't going to work like it should.

Hopefully it will be all ok.

Rather worrying a skoda dealership would suggest it's ok to drive like that.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeh - it wasn't like that when collecting the car.  Only since I've had it the last 4 weeks.

I think their suggestion that it was ok to drive, was based on the assumption that my panicked phone call was indicating there was a "slight oil film" on the coolant, rather than a half-inch thick layer or scum.

Probably just miscommunication at the time..... as soon as they saw the photos, they rang me and said "yeh mate, don't drive it like that."

 

4 days later - the service shop is still waiting for Skoda Australia to tell them what to do.... I suspect it's just a paperwork trail that needs to be done, to approve the warranty repair..... but they haven't told me exactly what the problem is yet.

All they've told me is that they SUSPECT it's a broken oil cooler.... but I won't have a definite answer until next week now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Community Partner

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to BRISKODA. Please note the following important links Terms of Use. We have a comprehensive Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.