Last month, I dropped from an L&K Superb to a Sportline Karoq. It’s the same 2 litre engine and the kit is almost the same due to getting added extras on the Karoq like heated seats and windscreen. My biggest surprise was the reduced mpg on the Karoq due to the 4x4. The Superb was really efficient, giving around 40 mpg both in local driving and motorways. I knew that I’d take some mpg hit because the car before the Superb was a 1.4 Tiguan with 4x4, which was really disappointing on fuel and spun the front wheels during acceleration. It was comfortable to drive, but hardly a fun experience. The Karoq’s bigger engine is much better for me and, as others have noted, there’s reassurance in knowing that the 4x4 will help in poor road conditions. I’d suggest that you go for the bigger engine.
As an extra thought, I tend to buy nearly new cars and don’t use PCP deals. I’ve found that you can get attractive prices on ex-demo and similar vehicles. I also found that my local dealer, Marshalls, is keen to pull in cash in these hard times and therefore would rather be extra competitive on price, rather than having cars hanging around for ages. I was pleased with my trade-in price for the Superb. I also waited a while and monitored the Karoq's price. When they took £1500 off, that made my decision for me and I took the plunge on the Karoq. So far, I've been impressed at how really easy it is to drive compared to the limo-length Superb, even though I loved the Superb!