Skip to content

17s vs 18s on vRS!

Featured Replies

Well, did the swap today, took off the 17s that came on the car, and swapped them for some 18s. :)

The (rubbish) pics speak for themselves really...

DSC00356.jpg

DSC00357.jpg

DSC00341.jpg

DSC00354.jpg

One of each!! :rofl:

DSC00342.jpg

Suprisingly, the 18s don't weigh much more than the 17s, and the ride is only a tad more jittery... but the car feels much tighter on turn in, and less dive under braking. Needless to say they will be staying on the car!!! :thumbup:

1.jpg

6.jpg

Lot better mate!!

Car is looking hot.

Looks much better.

Re-spraying the car from pink to red was a good move too :rofl:

  • Author

Cheers Harry.

Got 20mm spacers on the back now too - will get a separate thread up about them :)

  • Author
Looks much better.

Re-spraying the car from pink to red was a good move too :rofl:

:rofl:

The latter pics were taken on my Canon IXUS 700, the pink ones on my K850i - I've checked and double checked the settings, but it just won't take a decent photo :( Theres dust under the lens cover as well which is impossible to get out as its a sealed unit :(

So will the 17's be appearing on a silver 1.9 TDI hatch in Wiltshire soon?

Looks good.... as most women say that extra inch does make a difference :D

  • Author
So will the 17's be appearing on a silver 1.9 TDI hatch in Wiltshire soon?

Looks good.... as most women say that extra inch does make a difference :D

I couldn't possibly say ;)

So will the 17's be appearing on a silver 1.9 TDI hatch in Wiltshire soon?

Looks good.... as most women say that extra inch does make a difference :D

Especially when you have 4 of them........

It looks well Tom, lovely colour too, it's just a shame you won't be keepimg it:D

:rofl:

The latter pics were taken on my Canon IXUS 700, the pink ones on my K850i - I've checked and double checked the settings, but it just won't take a decent photo :( Theres dust under the lens cover as well which is impossible to get out as its a sealed unit :(

Mate, the reason for the 'dusty' appearance on the pics is because you have taken the first set into the sun, never a good idea. Always try to make sure the sun is behind you.

Not that I am any David Bailey

  • Author
Mate, the reason for the 'dusty' appearance on the pics is because you have taken the first set into the sun, never a good idea. Always try to make sure the sun is behind you.

Not that I am any David Bailey

Whilst this may be true, EVERY pic I've ever taken with the phone has been pants, including many others of the car, and they all look pink :(

It's a lovely shade of pink you've managed to capture though :)

Whilst this may be true, EVERY pic I've ever taken with the phone has been pants, including many others of the car, and they all look pink :(

I find that cameras in phones are always crap. Simply not up to the job.

Far better to use your Ixus.

Wish I had bought a red one now.

  • Author

So, 18s are definitely better than 17s then? :rofl:

So, 18s are definitely better than 17s then? :rofl:

Of course - it's a known fact :thumbup:

So, 18s are definitely better than 17s then? :rofl:

Not always! It depends on your outlook -

Looks - Well OK most people (that know what they are looking at) will prefer 18", me included. Certainly its the fashion at present and the marketing men are enjoying it.

Ride - difficult to quantify as suspension, tyres, etc are also influencing factors on this; but in general expect the ride on 18s to be slightly less supple than on 17s (but not by much).

Weight - I have sets of both 17" and 18" wheel/tyres both pretty 'standard' and the 18s are 2.5kg heavier per wheel/tyre. This will affect the ride/handling of the car.

Handling - the 18s will be sharper on turn in and more responsive in the dry (as a consequence of the shorter sidewall) but this can work against them in the wet (or cold) when the 17s will give a more forgiving and progressive response that can actually be faster.

In the EVO magazine tyre test 2007 where they tested tyres in 225/45 17 they used a Golf GTi that came with 225/40 18s and as a prelim and familiarisation on the wet handling circuit they put in a few practice laps. When they later did the actual test on 17s the car was a whole 2.5 sec per lap (around 65 seconds) quicker on the 17s!!

Food for thought (and discussion).

I will agree that the 18's look good and indeed better than the 17's but I prefer the 17's for 2 reasons- They will give a slightly better ride and they are £40 a corner cheaper to replace the rubber.

Steve

  • Author

Well I just paid £128 for a pair of 18" Falken 452s delivered - how cheap are your 17s!!! :P

Well I just paid £128 for a pair of 18" Falken 452s delivered - how cheap are your 17s!!! :P

Where did you get those from Tom?

  • Author

I know! :P

Whilst this may be true, EVERY pic I've ever taken with the phone has been pants, including many others of the car, and they all look pink :(

I took some pics of Katie's Clio when she was putting it up for sale on here and on Autotrader.

I was amazed that my Nokia N73 made it look better than my Canon Ixus 50 - no idea why and it could well be I had something set wrong but this is what I got.

N73....

ClioNokiaN73.jpg

Ixus 50....

ClioCanonIxus50.jpg

My Falkens are £42.

Don't forget that the £40 cheaper is probably on the fitted price as opposed to the tyre only price.

18's are deffinately way better than the 17's Tom :thumbup:

18's look spot on, glad I went out of my way to find one with them one

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.