To day i noticed a whining or a winding noise but it very low compared to the one on the video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mi2t_VT6YWg and generaly @ 1st and 2nd then desapear (when motor sound become louder i can't hear it). @ 3, 4 and 5 it's difficult to hear it. Is that  normal ?

PS : i have a manual gearbox and 10000 miles

 

https://www.quora.com/Is-it-normal-for-a-manual-transmission-car-to-make-a-whining-noise

 

http://www.transmissionrepaircostguide.com/10-common-transmission-problems/

Edited 26 January, 201610 yr by didou25

What motor is it? The supercharger in a TSI motor will whine noticeably if you have a window down, especially if you are in sport mode.

I was assuming a Manual by the video of the manual truck.

So Diesel, Petrol, what model.

But i know nothing about manuals.

would it be the same car you spoke about in this thread? the HTP? 

 

http://www.briskoda.net/forums/topic/382978-fabia-ii-12-htp-acceleration/#entry4480040

 

whats the whine like? dont tell me the gearbox is buggered too? 

would it be the same car you spoke about in this thread? the HTP? 

 

http://www.briskoda.net/forums/topic/382978-fabia-ii-12-htp-acceleration/#entry4480040

 

whats the whine like? dont tell me the gearbox is buggered too? 

Yes it's the same, the noise can be heard only from the interior when the windows are closed and the radio off it's the same sound you get from the revers gear (hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm), i didn't gave any attention to this until few day ago when i was driving without radio. i'll record it. regarding the acceleration problem every thing is normal according to my dad and to every one who drove it.   

Edited 27 January, 201610 yr by didou25

2015 Fabia, 1.2 HTP, 70 Hp, Manual Transmission, 10000 miles

Today i gave it to a friend, he drived it in a parking and the noise can not be heard from the outside 

Edited 27 January, 201610 yr by didou25

I tested it again and i found :

 

Whining @ 1st from 1000 to 3000 rpm

Whining @ 2nd under 2100 rpm

Whining @ 3rd under 2100 rpm

Whining @ 4th under 2100 rpm 

@ 5 th dificult to detect

 

The sound is similar to the one produced by the electric window motor and the one made by the reverse gear but lower then these 2.

 

Sombody told me that the motor is a bit quiet (good sound insolation) that's why i can hear the gear box.

 

http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=1990484

Edited 27 January, 201610 yr by didou25

its still under warranty isnt it? 

its still under warranty isnt it? 

Yes but my dealers mechanics are not very good they damaged some cars and i am 100% sure that they are going to tel me every thing is good since the gear change is very smooth.

Edited 27 January, 201610 yr by didou25

But you are asking strangers that can not guess what the issue is.

 

Where are you, is there no other Dealerships near with good technicians, or ask an Independent Mechanic to try driving your car 

and give an opinion.

But you are asking strangers that can not guess what the issue is.

 

Where are you, is there no other Dealerships near with good technicians, or ask an Independent Mechanic to try driving your car 

and give an opinion

I'm just asking about the sound if they have it or not, do your car make similar noise (a humming @ low rpm in 1st and 2nd)

Edited 27 January, 201610 yr by didou25

Yes but my dealers mechanics are not very good they damaged some cars and i am 100% sure that they are going to tel me every thing is good since the gear change is very smooth.

Maybe try another dealership then?

It doesnt have to be the one you purchased the car off, and Skoda dealership will do (:

Maybe try another dealership then?

It doesnt have to be the one you purchased the car off, and Skoda dealership will do (:

But did you noticed something similar to what i did describe

But did you noticed something similar to what i did describe

My gearbox doesnt whine in any gear, at any speed

My gearbox doesnt whine in any gear, at any speed

Even in reverse

Even in reverse

 

It does make that noise in reverse if you speed up that every car makes. Its just the way the gearbox works. That whine in reverse is perfectly normal. 

Edited 27 January, 201610 yr by fabiamk2SE

As said above, the whine in reverse is perfectly normal and happens in every car, it's because the gear for reverse has straight teeth and all the others have teeth that go diagonally on the cogs so they engage smoother.

 

However the other noises shouldn't happen.

I made this record it might help 

 

1st gear (0:00 => 0:20); 2nd; 3rd

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubuyh9Y7Xe4&feature=youtu.be

Edited 28 January, 201610 yr by didou25

I found this on youtube. Similar sound for the first 15 sec

 

Its really quite difficult to tell off a video even.

Is it defo the gearbox and not the 3 cylinder howl which is normal?

Ie. Does it do it in neutral?

Its really quite difficult to tell off a video even.

Is it defo the gearbox and not the 3 cylinder howl which is normal?

Ie. Does it do it in neutral?

Nothing in neutral,

can any one make a record of noises that can be heard inside the car

can any one make a record of noises that can be heard inside the car

Of what, a normal fully working htp?

Yes, but from inside the car when moving @ 1st and 2nd from 1000 to 2500 rpm