Skip to content

EFB or AGM Battery ?

Featured Replies

  • Author

A run of around 10 miles, in several stages today, was enough to trigger the Stop/Start to work, again, even in the dark with the headlights on. I'm impressed, but don't understand what  improvement the intelligent charger has been able to make to the system.

  • Replies 83
  • Views 16.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • The only really reliable way to test the condition of the battery is - 1 - Give it a full charge with suitable charger, ideally, a 'smart' charger. 2 - After full charge achieved, remove sur

  • Sorry to say but not the case. The way the current monitor works is it monitors the return path to the battery.    You can put the negative of a charger wherever you want on the car as long

  • The car maintains the battery at different levels depending on the driving state in the moment as well as other factors.   You keep using very non specific terms like ‘voltage were normal fo

Posted Images

You have put more charge into the battery.  As long as the battery holds the charge and/or you are not depleting the battery storage to how it was previously the start/stop should work (when it should) and you'll not get that and possibly other warnings.

 

Running the battery down low does it no favours, doing it too much and/or too often will weaken it and make it difficult to recover it as much as if you didn't.

 

Think of preventative charging or a battery maintainer or disconnecting the battery if the car isn't going to be used for weeks on end, that will extend the use and life of your existing battery and its replacement.

 

Don't wait for warning lights or messages to come on, be proactive rather than reactive.

 

Or buy a new battery and have to do less, until the cycle begins again.

 

Good luck.

 

Edited by nta16

  • 3 weeks later...

Hi, I own a Skoda rapid 2016 92KW 1.4tsi Spaceback Monte Carlo model. It has auto start stop function but it is fitted with a conventional battery from previous owner which is causing problems with idling and stalling and doesn’t support start stop function. Can someone suggest a battery either EFB or AGM that it needs to run normal.

thanks in advance.

@Vam as above best to have a EFB or AGM battery and 'coded' correctly particularly if you want or have to have the stop/start system active.

 

But an alternative in short or medium or perhaps long term, depending on how old your conventional battery is and its life's use and abuse you could retain it for longer (or much longer) by charging it up and if your state laws allow it disconnecting the battery monitor connection at the negative battery connection so that the stop/start system is inactive.

 

VCDS isn't the only system that can do the battery coding, basically as put before you want the Ah of the battery correct (or near enough perhaps) and the type e.g EFB/AGM (fleece) and change the "serial number" often/sometimes(?) ten ones (1111111111) from the VW's factory, the make is of battery can be left the same or ignored, JCB from factory and to five characters in the name code in my example below done with an OBDEleven computer program.

 

batterycoding.jpg.f8d43787411757e730ebdb8587d98627.jpg

 

I have no idea if the VW computer programs would allow you to 'code' on VCDS or the VW 'coding' programs to conventional battery and get it charged through the car's battery computer program but if it didn't make the stop/start inactive you would want to otherwise it would get through a conventional battery quicker.

 

Thanks for the response.

 

My mech had changed the battery and fitted a new EFB battery. But he said it doesn’t require programming or registration.

 

EPC light still comes and goes and Auto Start/Stop still doesn’t work. Car behave sluggish during idle intermittently. Cam and crankshaft sensor errors also throw up and car makes whirring noise during the start and goes off intermittently after engine heat up.

 

He scanned for error codes and got “oil pressure regulator valve error”.

 

He said he will try to program and register it tomorrow.

 

Engine light blinking and misfires still happen intermittently even after replacing the battery.

 

Will update tomorrow. Thanks.

 

 

35 minutes ago, Vam said:

 

My mech had changed the battery and fitted a new EFB battery. But he said it doesn’t require programming or registration.

 

 

Find a new tech....

 

As per my comment above....This applies to ALL cars with the "stop/start" eco function....

 

Even if the new battery is the exact same type/capacity/brand as the original factory one, you still need to alter the code line "serial number" by one digit to "tell" the BCM that a new battery has been installed & for it to forget all the old learnt values as a nice new battery has been installed.

 

 

39 minutes ago, Vam said:

My mech had changed the battery and fitted a new EFB battery. But he said it doesn’t require programming or registration.

I would disagree with your mech.

 

If the battery is exactly the same specs (type, Ah, etc.), then you should at least just change the serial number so that the BMS can  know a new battery is fitted straight away - yes it will learn over a longish period but surely you want to be able to use the full capability of a new battery you've just paid $$$ for straight away?

 

If the battery has different specs then you IMHO must tell the BMS the new specs ASAP.

3 hours ago, Vam said:

He scanned for error codes and got “oil pressure regulator valve error”.

 

He said he will try to program and register it tomorrow.

Does this mean program and register the oil pressure regulator valve, or the new EFB battery or both?

 

I can't see the point of a tech fitting a new battery and having an appropriate scan tool for the job and not doing at least changing the serial number and it would be good if he gave you a report of the car as it is when he first scanned it showing battery details and all error codes and then another report after he 'codes' for the new battery and has deleted all error codes that will delete.

 

There was a chap with another model who despite having an appropriate scan tool left the battery change and coding to a professional auto-electrician and months later was on the forum because of battery and other problems and  he followed the suggestion of checking the battery 'coding' to find the professional auto-electrician had made the mistake of entering 7 Ah instead of 70 Ah (why the computer program allowed this is another mistake to me).  The chap fitted a new battery and 'coded' it himself and his problems went away.

 

I am not saying that all your problems, or possibly any of them, are now related to the battery 'coding' because I and others can't see the information or known what the tech has fully done or not done and you might have more than one issue with the car but personally I would want to be shown or emailed a a scan report showing the present battery coding and preferably also a scan report from the first scan as we can all make mistakes and I see no reason why a tech should not give you such information.  It should be saved on his machine particularly if his repairs and (hopefully) diagnosis is ongoing.

 

A scan tool is another diagnosis tool that gives information that needs to be interpreted, it can sometimes point directly at the origin of a problem,  as perhaps here, or present information for the tech to asses and diagnosis what the problem might be.  Again I am not saying the following is the case here just general info for you, some people just shoot the massager and change the part that gives bad news show on the scan tool.

 

Good luck, let us know how you get on.

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

Welcome to BRISKODA. Please note the following important links Terms of Use. We have a comprehensive Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.

Account

Navigation

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.